- Revecore Insights
What It Takes to Overturn the Hardest Denials
November 20, 2026
Hospitals spent $43 billion in 2025 trying to collect payments insurers owe for care already delivered, according to the American Hospital Association’s latest Costs of Caring report. Nearly $18 billion of that went toward overturning claim denials. Automation now absorbs much of the routine, high-volume work behind those numbers. It is far less effective on denials that turn on contract language, federal procedure or a contested clinical judgment. Too often, those are the accounts that get written off.
What makes a denial complex
A routine denial usually needs a correction. A complex one needs an argument. These categories most often call for one:
Authorization disputes
Non-covered service determinations
Out-of-network claims
Investigational and experimental denials
ERISA-governed appeals
Out-of-network claims show the gap clearly. KFF’s analysis of HealthCare.gov plans found insurers denied 37% of out-of-network claims in 2024, nearly double the 19% rate for in-network claims.
Many of these denials are worth contesting. In a JAMA Internal Medicine study of roughly 51,000 external appeals in New York, the share of denials overturned by independent reviewers rose from 38% in 2019 to nearly 53% in 2025.
Why ERISA appeals sit in their own category
The Department of Labor estimates roughly 136 million participants and beneficiaries are covered by approximately 2.6 million ERISA-covered group health plans. About 78.4 million of those people are enrolled in self-insured plans, which Georgetown University’s Center on Health Insurance Reforms notes are exempt from state insurance regulation. The state-level rules a revenue cycle team relies on with fully insured products generally do not reach these claims.
Federal rules take their place. Under the Department of Labor’s claims procedure regulation, group health plans must allow at least 180 days to appeal, conduct a review that gives no deference to the original denial, and consult a qualified health care professional when a denial rests on medical judgment. That includes experimental and investigational determinations. These protections help only when someone on the hospital side knows how to invoke them.
A 2025 Fifth Circuit decision shows how much depends on the details. Fifty-six Texas emergency physician groups alleged that 24 out-of-state Blue Cross Blue Shield plans underpaid their claims. The court revived claims supported by written assignments of benefits and upheld judgment for the plans on claims without them. Assignment language, anti-assignment clauses and exhaustion questions shaped the outcome before the court ever reached what the plans owed.
How a layered appeal is built
Complex denials benefit from a multipronged approach. The strongest appeals combine three types of argument in a single dispute:
Procedural: applicable state and federal law, extenuating-circumstance policies and claim-handling deficiencies
Contractual: the terms of the hospital’s payer agreement and the payer’s own policies
Clinical: a review of the medical record that ties the services provided to the coverage criteria
Each layer covers gaps in the others. A payer may hold firm on a clinical point and still have missed a regulatory deadline or misapplied its own contract.
The harder constraint is capacity. In 2024, the average hospital employed about 64 administrative and billing staff dedicated to these functions, per the AHA. Researching plan documents and drafting a multilayered argument for one high-dollar account still demands specialized expertise and time that most teams cannot spare.
Revecore’s Legal Appeals service was designed for this category of denials. It is staffed by in-house attorneys, leveraging Revecore’s ReClaim™ platform, who apply a layered approach of contractual, procedural, and clinical arguments to dispute denials that require more than a templated appeal letter to resolve. The service includes support for ERISA claims, giving hospitals a path to pursue appeals. Attorneys work as an integrated extension of the hospital’s billing office, so internal teams can pursue revenue they’ve earned without having to build this capability in-house.
See how Revecore helps hospitals pursue complex and ERISA-governed denials.
Similar Content
-
- Revecore Insights
- Denials Management
Every Denial You Don’t Appeal Teaches the Algorithm Something
November 10, 2026
-
- Revecore Insights
What Health Systems Need to Get Right Before Agentic AI Can Run the Revenue Cycle
November 9, 2026
-
- Revecore Insights
Accuracy Is the Common Ground in the AI Coding Debate
November 5, 2026